Skip to content
Urbanity Craft Groningen

Which Players Have Earned a Spot in Troy's Premier League Weekly Best XI?

Following every single round of Premier League fixtures this season, BBC soccer expert Troy Deeney selects his team and gaffer of the week.

Here are this week's choices. What are your thoughts? Provide your feedback.

The Last Line of Defense

Jordan Pickford (Everton): A pivotal incident in the Toffees' comprehensive victory against Chelsea came from his brilliant denial to prevent a goal from Enzo Fernandez. The goalkeeper has delivered when it counts in key instances for his club this season and, fans will hope, he maintains this form for England at the upcoming World Cup. A week ago, he made a significant error versus Arsenal but has picked himself up admirably to perform for the Toffees.

Defensive Unit

Neco Williams (Nottingham Forest): It was a enormous crunch game for Forest when they visited Tottenham, with top-flight survival at stake for both sides. And Williams produced a colossal display to guide his side get a vital three points in the battle against the drop. He registered a pair of assists, delivering when it counted.

Matty Cash (Aston Villa): In my view, West Ham provided a major threat in attack but Cash was solid and held the line for Villa. He managed to just maintaining possession. He supplied a lot going forward and also managed to shut down all the Hammers attempted in the final third.

James Tarkowski (Everton): It was yet another reliable performance from the Everton defender. He showed his experience and control, and reliably where he needed to be. He produced important interventions when required and, crucially, was a calming figure in their defense. How Chelsea would love a central defender with that kind of gumption, especially given the shaky defending they have shown at times.

Engine Room

Chris Rigg (Sunderland): It amounted to a solid performance from Rigg in a historic Tyne-Wear derby. He did not do anything spectacular against Newcastle but he did everything really, really well. With Rigg, you are aware of the level of performance from him.

James Garner (Everton): He easily could have taken it easy on the back of getting called up to the Three Lions squad recently. But instead, he cracked on and put in a great shift. It came in the form of a lovely pass from him to Beto for Everton's first goal. Having played with him at Watford, I know he's synonymous with high energy and physical presence. He is the complete package and I trust he performs for England to force his way into that World Cup final roster.

John McGinn (Aston Villa): He's their skipper, leader and heartbeat. It's been a pair of huge performances in the space of a week from him. Villa are a decent side. But McGinn makes them a top one. If they hope to finish in the Champions League places and compete for the Europa League title, they depend on him to keep producing at these heights.

Harry Wilson (Fulham): He has cultivated a knack of getting big goals and he repeated the trick again in the latest round. I wonder how they will fill the void if he opts to depart. They won't spend £60m on a player with his attributes. They require him to sign a new contract as he is a massively important piece of that Cottagers squad.

Front Line

Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United): It feels like the Portuguese midfielder is turning into a staple in the weekly best XI. You must include him again following one more goal, and additionally forcing the James Hill own goal. How long can United stay average and keep him before he determines it is the right moment to exit the club?

Beto (Everton): On this occasion, we have a pair of strikers who are at opposite points in their professional journey. I am not sure Beto is a long-term solution for the Merseyside club's goalscoring woes, but manager David Moyes is getting a tune out of him right now. It is remarkable considering how ineffective he was earlier in the season.

Danny Welbeck (Brighton): He was omitted by Thomas Tuchel once more for the national team, at a point when they require cover to skipper Harry Kane. But Welbeck kept on perform for the Albion with a double, to overcome title holders Liverpool, and increase his goal count to twelve goals for the season.

Manager of the Week

David Moyes (Everton): The game between Everton and Chelsea was a classic encapsulation of old school against new school. Blues boss Liam Rosenior is still trying to establish himself at the start of his coaching journey but Moyes put together a flawless strategy to engineer a dominant victory. The Toffees were bolder and more robust in every aspect of the game and it was a massive win for them.

Do you agree with Deeney's picks? Name your weekly best XI? Have your say.

The writer

Frank Vargas

Lena is an architect and design enthusiast based in Groningen, sharing her passion for contemporary urban spaces.

Urbanity Craft Groningen

Type to search articles.